Phish in Telluride: A Review

Phish Returns to Telluride
Review by Adam Perry for Boulder Weekly
(photos by Adam Perry)

Monday and Tuesday, thousands of white people from all over the country gathered in the verdant splendor of Telluride to shout David Bowie’s name over and over beneath the mountains. In other words, after a much-needed five-year hiatus, the versatile, talented and amusing Vermont quartet Phish is back—and things have changed.

Gone are the drugs (at least for the band), embarrassingly sloppy transitions, hit-or-miss half-hour improvisations and unruly distorted-guitar sound the band featured their last time on the road together, from 2002-2004. Plus, Phish has somehow managed to escape the quagmire that doomed its two-set jamband predecessors The Grateful Dead, namely sticking to massive, distancing concerts in arenas, stadiums and ugly amphitheatres for audiences ranging from 20,000 people to 70,000.

Phish’s two shows in Telluride earlier this week (my first since Miami 2003) sold out in just a few minutes when tickets were released months ago, and represented the group’s first southern Colorado performances since 1991. Both the band and the city of Telluride took every precaution necessary to host one of the world’s biggest touring bands at a small mountainside fairground that holds around 9,000 people and coincidentally sits at approximately 9,000 feet above sea level.


The group’s management approved my press pass just days before Phish’s much-anticipated return to Telluride—its first shows outside of Vermont were in Telluride circa 1988— and when I made the (gorgeous) drive from Santa Fe to Telluride the morning of the first three-hour concert, I was impressed by the barricade preventing anyone without a ticket or proof of residency from entering town. I was also impressed—and excited—that a free gondola ride was necessary to reach the venue, which is a concert experience I’ll never forget.

The first night, Phish picked “Down With Disease” as their opener; the crowd-pleasing rocker, which earned Phish some rare airplay when it was released as a single in 1994, got the crowd bouncing, more than a few with happy kids on their shoulders. Sadly, the rest of the opening set was somewhat of a stinker, despite the absolutely immaculate outdoor setting, which prompted singer/guitarist Trey Anastasio to comment, “Yup, it’s still beautiful.” Two new songs, “Ocelot” and “Summer of ’89,” ran the gamut of unremarkable to downright terrible, and the intricate Latin prog-rock workout “Stash” (from 1991’s A Picture of Nectar) never really took flight. However, Phish redeemed itself throughout the first evening’s closing set, which featured clear and concise virtuosity from Anastasio and oddball bassist Mike Gordon during the heavy funk-rock of “Sand” and Stevie Wonder’s “Boogie On Reggae Woman.”

After a brisk, ecstatic version of “Piper,” a poetic avalanche of improvisation-seeped ascension that the group has been using as a springboard since 1997, the quartet got beautifully weird. This is the Phish I’ve always loved, and always tried to turn others on to: Instead of simply letting Anastasio wank on predictable blues scales and intermittently reach occasionally euphoric high notes while the rest of the band supports him, Phish sometimes uses the open spaces after songs like “Piper” to truly melt into a kind of deconstructed ambiance. The music Phish spontaneously creates in these possibility-laden spaces often juxtaposes fusion-era Miles Davis, Brian Eno and the kind of wonderfully twisted instrumental rock made famous by bands such as Neu! and Sonic Youth.

To see Phish play an entire hour-long set of this dark, spacey improvisational music was a dream I had fulfilled at a show in Maine back in 2003, but these days Phish is more of a well-rehearsed rock band, for better or worse, than an experimentation-inclined outfit. Real group improvisation—outside of a song structure and outside of simply propping up Anastasio’s guitar solos—was relegated to perhaps ten minutes of the first show in Telluride. The second set on Monday concluded with a spot-on version of the Beatles’ classic “A Day in the Life,” and that’s certainly nothing to complain about. It was incredible.

At least as incredible was a hike I took to Telluride’s wonderful Cornet Creek Falls before Tuesday’s concert while many people in town were hung-over or asleep. I was sober for both shows and found it…interesting…to witness not only the drug-fueled transformation that occurred each day for thousands of fans—some diehards following Phish from town to town on tour, but most not—but also the sight of these same unwashed, shabbily clothed trainwrecks at expensive bistros before each show. It takes a special person to ingest copious amounts of marijuana, psychedelics, cocaine and who knows what else until dawn and then spend $20 on a breakfast burrito and orange juice.

For the members of Phish, anyway, music has finally become the drug of choice. Anastasio did a court-ordered rehab stint a few years ago after getting busted in upstate New York, and many of the songs from the band’s latest release, last year’s Joy, reflect his humbling journey. “Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan,” for instance, a brutal new half-time dirt-rocker that falls somewhere between Gov’t Mule and Phish’s own “The Sloth,” was a highlight of the first set on Tuesday, with its cutting chorus of “got a blank space where my mind should be.”

It was a treat to be just feet away from Phish for the second show in Telluride, as the group operates without a setlist and up-close audience members can hear Anastasio call out the tunes he chooses and then watch the news run through the hierarchy down to drummer Jon Fishman, who is always the last to know what song he’s about to play. After a spirited version of the 1930’s work song “Timber (Jerry)” Anastasio called for Phish’s own 25-year-old irreverent-and-inspiring fugue “The Divided Sky,” only to be nixed by Gordon, who suggested “Let Me Lie,” off of Joy. That song’s recurring couplet “gonna take my bike out / gonna ride it just how I like” helps make “Let Me Lie” the single worst Phish tune I’ve ever heard. Honestly, it’s mediocre at best musically, but lyrically it’s literally embarrassing to watch someone sing it. Thank God “Let Me Lie” was indeed followed by a gorgeous version of “The Divided Sky,” complete with Anastasio intently gazing at the mountain sunset during his remarkable solo.

Though this will surprise those who have strong opinions about the band but haven’t actually heard its music, Phish’s two biggest direct musical influences have been Frank Zappa and the Talking Heads. Phish alternately pulls off the high-wire tricks featured in complex compositions such as “The Divided Sky” and “You Enjoy Myself” (which was also played, and played very well, Tuesday) and grooves on warped funk and rock with silly lyrics and profound music. Which made the band’s covers of the James Gang’s “Walk Away” and Ween’s “Roses Are Free” perfect follow-ups to the tricky “Divided Sky.”

The unexpected musical highlight of the two shows in Telluride, however, was “Carini.” A hilarious nu-metal poke at Fishman’s drum technician Pete Carini, the song—which debuted in 1997 —provides a back-and-forth heavy-rock/ambient noise platform for group improvisation. On Tuesday night “Carini” descended into an explosive instrumental freakout reminiscent of Adrian Belew’s early work with King Crimson, but was tempered by shimmering noise that recalled the aforementioned Eno and surprisingly found its way to the Phish hard-rock staple “Free.”

Watching four men in their 40s who have been playing music together since their college days over 25 years ago is a treat in itself, but it was doubly entertaining to witness Phish nailing challenging transitions in songs like “Run Like An Antelope” and “David Bowie.” In the two years of touring before their five-year hiatus from 2004-2009, it was not uncommon for Phish to literally stop during such complex tunes because of flubs by several band members; now, the transitions are tighter, the smiles are bigger (and straighter) and the jamming is not only shorter but less intense, group-minded and creative—or at least it was for all but a few minutes of the Telluride shows.

Many Phish fans will agree that five minutes of fun, focused, coherent and energetic improvisation often trumps 30 minutes of scrambled drudgery. Still, listening to a Phish concert from Hampton, VA circa 1997 on the way back to Santa Fe I had to admit that my personal preference is the old four or five song, hour and a half set of improvised Phish madness, rather than the dozen-song sets that Phish often plays today.

I also had to admit that there are plenty of modern bands I’ve seen recently who are writing better songs and putting on better shows than Phish—who concluded Tuesday’s concert with The Rolling Stones’ “Shine a Light”—but there certainly aren’t many venues in the world more spectacular than Telluride Town Park.

16 thoughts on “Phish in Telluride: A Review

  1. Such a sober review….Hope you took your nalgene bottle full of water on your day hike ..Better pull up your socks and tighten your daypack ..You know irritability is the first sign of dehydration …Light up or leave me alone a first night , first set stinker?Mike Gordon is on fire, They have to lower his Bass in with a crane !!!!!!More improv is always nice but you obviously missed the Fun Bus…I’ve seen Phish from the beginning, had the time of my life on this amazing weekday weekend and didn’t touch a drop of alcohol..Nothings Perfect…As for you wooks buying high dollar breakfast burritos in scantily clad clothing after partying all night, Thanks for not f’ing up the town,Hopefully we get to come back and this reviewer is stuck covering one of the other, better LIVE bands than Phish …Cuz we all know they don’t exist..

    1. First of all, I’m glad you enjoyed the show – I did, too – and I’m also glad that everyone has different tastes. Sure, there was probably a time in the ’90s when Phish put on a better live show than any band in the world, partly due to writing great songs and partly due to play seamless, unpredictable and exciting sets that included lots of group improvisation that hit not only on “In a Silent Way”-type fusion but darker experimentation in the vein of Neu! and King Crimson.

      In Telluride, at least, there were only perhaps 15 minutes total group improvisation – read: not just three guys supporting a lead guitarist’s soloing – and a display of some mediocre new songs. It was a fun two nights, and there were some very high points, but I certainly didn’t walk about thinking “no band exists right now in the world who is better live than Phish.” I’ve seen lots of shows in the past few years that were better than Phish, at least better than the level they’re playing at right now. If I just want to see a great soloist, there are a lot of jazz musicians who are more skilled than Trey Anastasio, and if I want to see great songs I’ll gladly see Fleet Foxes, Andrew Bird, Midlake, Jolie Holland and on and on.

      But once again, that’s my taste.

  2. Adam perry, you are an idiot and a terrible reporter. It makes me upset to know that you were there instead of a real fan that would have had the time of their life.

    1. Thanks, Jim smith. You seem like a really nice guy. Look, if being a “real” Phish fan means not only unconditionally lapping up every note Phish plays but also never daring to listen to other music, count me out. Sometimes they play brilliantly, deeply and uniquely, sometimes they just plain stink, and sometimes they’re a fun bar-type band doing zany covers. To each his or her own.

  3. Adam Perry, how DARE you bring your entire brain to the show and exercise your critical faculties like an actual writer instead of a slavish fanboy acting like a bunch of gifted former stoners from Vermont are less fallible than the Pope. Next time, remember only to use words like “burnin” and “meltdown” and “hetty.” Then we’ll know which side you’re on!

  4. this is perhaps the most inaccurate review I have read of the Telluride shows. While some of your points are valid, many are pretty far off track…saying the first set was a stinker, shows that you are either too close minded for Phish or that you have too high of expectations for music in general, learn how to have phun. Ocelot is a fun song, yes, it’s not the band’s greatest musical triumph, but it works and gets the crowd moving, after all, that is the point isn’t it? Most people I talked to at the show enjoyed Summer of ’89. It seems you don’t like change or new tunes, that’s too bad to be stuck in the mid to late ’90s. Evolve with the band and learn how to experience their ups and downs with them instead of being one of the crossed-arm stick in the mud fans taking up space.

    1. A lot of bar bands play “fun songs that get the crowd moving,” but I didn’t drive six hours to take drugs and cheer Phish through their shitty moments like it was the Special Olympics. That said, I genuinely enjoyed most of the music Phish played in Telluride; I really thought a few minutes of each night was transcendent; and I really thought some of it was terrible. My own personal opinion, that you don’t have to share, is that if Phish isn’t going to be doing a lot of deep group improvisation (which is why I, personally, go to see them) they better damn well be writing great songs that aren’t just so-so “get the crowd moving” filler, and there are countless bands currently writing much, much more quality songs than Phish.

  5. I agree with Steve Silberman. Adam should have taken so much Ecstasy at these shows, that he might have thought the splatter of a homeless man puking onto a garbage can was Rhapsody in Blue. That’s the only way to give unconditional love for two nights of hit and miss jam music.

  6. Hi Adam,

    I am a 10 year fan and this was a great concert festival for me. I go to the shows for the music and the fans. To meet interesting people, laugh with old friends, puff with a dead head and just to have fun dancing and singing with the songs I know.

    The experience was the scene, not the music alone.

    Keep your eyes open to new things and enjoy your stories that come from it.

    1. Thanks for your comment, Joe. I did meet some friendly fans in line and during the concerts who talked about traveling and talked about the music, but I also met a good number seriously drugged-up and obnoxious fans. Witnessing zombified people huddled in doorways after the shows sucking nitrous oxide out of balloons was depressing. Guess both the scene and the music have their ups and downs.

  7. “you have too high of expectations for music in general, learn how to have phun” – to me, Adam is demanding what a huge Phish fan should expect – the absolute brilliance Phish is capable of, which goes WAY beyond “phun.” A “real fan” understands what Phish is capable of – and, through truly listening to the music, knows when this mark is met, and when it’s not.
    I have heard Deadheads say, “if you just went for the music, you missed out.” Yes, this – the scene, the community, even the travel experience – is so much bigger than music and in this way, we never miss out, so long as those aspects are here. But that doesn’t mean we should ignore the music itself – The MUSIC is the spaceship where all this takes place. If the spaceship is low on gas, it’s just a fun launch party, soothing, but not transformational

    1. and I will add, the fact that Adam is willing to post these comments, negative as some are, shows his credibility as a journalist – not just protecting his opinion, but letting it all air

  8. Isn’t it funny how yu had to hold yourself above Phish by badmouthing them. FUck you loser. What have you ever done to judge. They were fucking great unlike your shitty writing

    1. Thanks, Jack. You seem like a nice guy, too. Let’s hang out sometime.

      Look, I was paid to cover the shows and really enjoyed most of the music, really loved some of it, and thought a little of it was terrible. That’s the case with most concerts, although one or two I see every year are truly great from start to finish. Still, I’ve got my Real Phish Fan lead ready for the Maine show I’m covering this fall:

      “Last night in Augusta, Phish proved that they are the four greatest musicians and songwriters in the history of our planet and should be elected Kings of the Universe. Although it will never happen because most people are fucking losers, it’s obvious that every radio station on Earth should play nothing but Phish and every television station nothing but Phish

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s